The History of NYC-Style Cookies: The Ultimate Thick and Gooey Treat

New York City is famous for its oversized, thick, and gooey cookies that have taken the dessert world by storm. From bakery windows to viral social media posts, these decadent, chunky cookies are now a global sensation. But where did they originate, and why have they become so popular? Let’s take a deep dive into the history of NYC-style cookies and why they’re a must-try for every cookie lover.

The Birth of NYC-Style Cookies

While traditional cookies have been enjoyed for centuries, the New York-style cookie as we know it today is a more recent invention. Unlike classic biscuits or thinner cookies, these thick, indulgent treats are designed to be crisp on the outside while remaining soft and gooey in the centre.

One of the most well-known pioneers of this cookie style is Levain Bakery, founded in 1995 by two friends, Pam Weekes and Connie McDonald. Originally created as an energy-packed snack for athletes, their massive, doughy cookies quickly became an NYC sensation. Soon, food lovers from all over the world flocked to their Upper West Side location to experience the magic of these chunky cookies.

What Makes NYC Cookies Different?

Unlike standard cookies, New York-style cookies stand out for their:

🍪 Larger-than-life size – These cookies are often 100g or more, making them thick and substantial.

🔥 Crisp exterior, gooey interior – Baked at high temperatures, NYC cookies develop a perfect golden crust while keeping the inside soft and slightly underbaked.

🍫 High-quality ingredients – From premium chocolate chunks to buttery-rich dough, these cookies prioritise flavour and texture over everything.

🎉 Unique flavour combinations – While classic chocolate chip remains a favourite, bakeries and home bakers now experiment with stuffed cookies, loaded toppings, and mix-ins like caramel, nuts, and cookies & cream.

The Rise of NYC-Style Cookies Around the World

With the rise of social media and food trends, NYC-style cookies have gained massive popularity beyond the streets of Manhattan. Viral videos showcasing the pull-apart gooey centres and melting chocolate chunks have fuelled a global craving for these indulgent cookies.

Now, bakeries worldwide are creating their own versions, offering everything from stuffed cookie pies to deluxe cookie flavours featuring ingredients like sea salt caramel, white chocolate, and Oreo biscuits.

Where to Get the Best NYC-Style Cookies

If you’re searching for the ultimate NYC-style cookie experience, look no further! Our deluxe cookies are inspired by the original New York bakery-style treats, offering the perfect balance of crispy, chewy, and gooey goodness. Whether you love classic chocolate chip, indulgent caramel-stuffed, or cookies & cream-loaded creations, we have the perfect cookie for you.

👉 Browse our collection and order your NYC-style cookies today!